Gold vs Mutual Funds: Which Is a Smarter Investment for the Long Term in 2025?
Gold is a reliable hedge and tax-efficient via SGBs, equity mutual funds remain the best long-term wealth creators for most Indians—use both in the right proportions based on your risk, goals, and time horizon.
Why this debate matters in 2025
For Indian savers, “Gold vs. Mutual Funds” isn’t just a weekend discussion—it’s a core portfolio decision. Gold is culturally trusted and tends to shine during crises. Mutual funds—especially equity funds—channel long-term economic growth and the power of compounding. With new capital-gains tax rules since July 23, 2024, plus the continuing popularity of Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs) and Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs), the 2025 playbook deserves a fresh look.
Quick Comparison: Gold vs Mutual Funds (2025)
Historical Returns
Gold: 8–10% annualized (long-term average in India, but with long stagnant periods).
Mutual Funds (Equity): 12–15% annualized over the past 15–20 years (Sensex/Nifty-based data).
Risk
Gold: Lower volatility, acts as a safe-haven asset during crises.
Mutual Funds: Higher volatility due to market dependence, but rewards long-term investors.
Liquidity
Gold: High liquidity; can be sold easily in physical, digital, or ETF form.
Mutual Funds: Moderate; redemption takes 1–3 working days depending on the fund type.
Taxation
Gold: Capital gains taxed; long-term (after 3 years) at 20% with indexation.
Mutual Funds:
- Equity funds: Long-term (after 1 year) at 10% above ₹1 lakh.
- Debt funds: Long-term (after 3 years) at 20% with indexation.
How to Invest
Gold: Physical gold, Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs), Gold ETFs, Digital gold.
Mutual Funds: Equity mutual funds, Debt mutual funds, Hybrid funds, Index funds, SIPs.
Historical Returns: What the last decade says
Equities vs. Gold, 2016–2025. Economic Times’ cross-asset study for 2016–2025 shows equity mid-caps as the best performer over ten years, with gold close behind, both beating inflation by a wide margin. Inflation (CPI) averaged 4.73% CAGR (May 2015–May 2025), so both asset classes delivered strong real returns. The big picture: equity outperformance over long windows remains intact, while gold proved its worth in risk-off phases and during global shocks.
Nifty 50 long-term context. NSE’s total-return facts over multiple long windows place the Nifty 50 in the low-teens CAGR range historically (TR index includes dividends), though outcomes vary by entry point and cycle. The takeaway is consistent: equities have historically compounded meaningfully for patient investors, despite sharp interim volatility.
Gold’s decade and new highs. Gold’s long-run case strengthened through monetary cycles and geopolitical stress. World Gold Council data tracks multi-year price trends and shows continuing investor interest; Indian rates even touched record territory in 2025 as global prices firmed. Use these histories as context—not guarantees—but they underscore why gold remains a core diversifier.
Bottom line: Over long periods, equities (via mutual funds) have the higher return ceiling, while gold has delivered solid real returns and portfolio protection—especially valuable in drawdowns. A blend often beats either alone on a risk-adjusted basis.
Risk & Volatility: What are you really signing up for?
Gold is not risk-free, but it usually zigs when equities zag, helping dampen overall portfolio swings. That negative/low correlation is why gold is widely used as a hedge against inflation, currency weakness, and market stress. Indian investors increasingly use Gold ETFs and SGBs instead of jewellery to capture market returns without making charges and storage risks.
Equity mutual funds come with higher day-to-day volatility, earnings cycles, and valuation swings. But when you stretch the horizon to 7–10+ years, market risk tends to compress, and earnings growth/India’s GDP trajectory show up in returns—especially with SIPs that average costs through ups and downs.
Liquidity & Convenience
Physical gold: emotional value and instant tangibility, but making charges, bid-ask spreads, and storage/security reduce efficiency.
Gold ETFs/Gold mutual funds: high liquidity, simple demat execution, NAV-linked pricing.
Sovereign Gold Bonds: tradable on exchanges, but best treated as buy-and-hold till maturity to realise their tax advantage; secondary liquidity/price discovery can be variable.
Mutual funds: purchase/redemption on any business day; SIPs offer “pay-yourself-first” automation.
Taxation Rules in 2025: What changed—and what it means
The capital-gains overhaul effective July 23, 2024 reshaped post-tax outcomes, especially for equity and gold vehicles. Here are the current essentials relevant to most readers in FY 2024–25 (AY 2025–26):
Equity mutual funds (equity-oriented)
LTCG on sales on/after July 23, 2024:
- ₹1.25 lakh annual exemption (up from ₹1 lakh).
- Gains above exemption taxed at 12.5%.
STCG (typically on holdings ≤12 months for equity): 20% after the reform.
These changes apply based on the sale date of the units; pre-change disposals follow the old rules. Always compute period-wise.
Gold exposure (ETFs, gold mutual funds, physical/digital)
Gold ETFs / gold mutual funds are treated as non-equity for tax purposes. Post-reform, long-term capital gains are taxed at 12.5% without indexation (after the current long-term holding period prescribed for that category), while short-term gains are taxed at your slab.
Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs)
- Interest: 2.5% per annum, taxable at your slab.
- Capital gains on redemption at maturity: fully tax-exempt for individuals.
- TDS: not applicable; investors must self-report.
This combination makes SGBs the most tax-efficient way to hold gold long term for many retail investors.
Note: There are evolving interpretations around how Section 87A rebate interacts with “special income” like STCG. Recent developments show legal ambiguity; follow authoritative updates or consult a tax professional for edge cases. The core LTCG/STCG rates and equity exemption above remain the policy anchor for planning.
How to Invest (Step-by-Step)
If you prefer Gold
1. Sovereign Gold Bonds (preferred for long-term)
Subscribe during RBI tranches or buy listed SGBs on exchanges via your broker.
Expect 2.5% interest (taxable) + capital-gains-free maturity redemption (8-year tenor; early exits possible via specified windows but forfeit tax-free maturity).
2. Gold ETFs / Gold Mutual Funds
Use a demat/brokerage (ETFs) or mutual fund platform (Gold MFs).
Pros: liquidity, purity, no storage risk.
Tax: LTCG 12.5% without indexation post-reform; STCG at slab.
3. Avoid jewellery for investment
Making charges, buy-sell spreads, and purity risks reduce effective returns. Use it for consumption, not investing. (Efficiency point consistent with market structure and WGC guidance/context.)
If you prefer Mutual Funds (equity-oriented)
1. Define your risk and horizon
Large-cap / index funds for core stability.
Flexi-cap / multi-cap for diversified equity exposure.
Mid-/small-cap only if you can stomach volatility and have 7–10+ years. (NSE long-run data supports equity compounding for long horizons.)
2. Use SIPs for discipline
Automate monthly contributions to average entry costs through cycles.
Combine with occasional lumpsum during deep corrections if your risk tolerance allows. (Cost-averaging logic grounded in long-term equity return dispersion.)
3. Keep costs low
Prefer direct-plan index funds/ETFs for core allocations; lower expense ratios add up over decades.
4. Mind the tax calendar
Track the ₹1.25 lakh equity LTCG exemption each FY, tactically harvest gains above threshold when appropriately.
Gold as an Inflation Hedge vs. Equities for Wealth Creation
Why Gold belongs in most Indian portfolios
Inflation and currency hedge: Gold often holds purchasing power when fiat weakens or inflation surprises.
Crisis insurance: During geopolitical or market shocks, gold’s defensive behaviour can offset equity drawdowns, smoothing your portfolio ride.
Diversification: Even a 5–15% sleeve can improve risk-adjusted returns for equity-heavy investors. (WGC and Indian holdings/AUM growth underscore adoption.)
Why Equities (via Mutual Funds) drive long-term wealth
Ownership of growth: Equities monetise India’s earnings expansion and productivity gains—drivers of long-term wealth creation.
Dividends + reinvestment (captured in total-return indices) boost compounding.
Historical evidence: Across long windows, equity returns have typically surpassed gold and fixed income, at the cost of higher interim volatility.
Conclusion of this section
Treat gold as a strategic diversifier and hedge, not your primary growth engine. Treat equity mutual funds as the core long-term compounder, sized to your risk tolerance.
What a Balanced Mix Might Look Like (Illustrative)
Back-tested mixes show that modest gold allocations can sometimes maintain similar 10-year returns while altering drawdown and volatility profiles. One analysis suggests that adding 10% gold to a 50/40/10 equity/debt/gold mix delivered 10.8% over the last decade—comparable to a 60/40 equity/debt mix without gold—highlighting diversification’s role. Your exact numbers will vary, but the diversification principle is robust.
Practical Scenarios & Model Portfolios (2025)
Important: These are illustrative allocation ideas, not personalised advice. Adjust for your goals, liabilities, and risk capacity.
1) Young, aggressive investor (Age 20–30, horizon 10–20 years)
70–90% Equity Mutual Funds (core in Nifty 50/large-cap index + flexi-cap; optional small allocation to mid/small-cap)
0–10% Debt (to handle emergencies outside of your emergency fund)
10–15% Gold (via SGBs for tax efficiency if you can hold to maturity; or Gold ETFs for liquidity)
Rationale: Maximise compounding while keeping a gold hedge for crises. Harvest equity LTCG judiciously above ₹1.25 lakh yearly threshold if needed.
2) Mid-career, balanced investor (Age 30–45, horizon 7–15 years)
50–65% Equity Mutual Funds (large/flexi-cap core; low-cost index preferred)
20–30% Quality Debt/Hybrid funds (stability and goal matching)
10–15% Gold (SGBs for long-term tax edge; ETFs if you value flexibility)
Rationale: Balance growth with stability; gold reduces portfolio stress in drawdowns, while debt supports near-term goals.
3) Conservative / near-retiree (Age 45+; horizon 3–7 years on major goals)
25–45% Equity Mutual Funds (tilt to large-cap/index)
35–55% Debt/Hybrid (ladder to match liabilities)
10–20% Gold, predominantly via SGBs (hold to maturity to realise tax-free capital gains)
Rationale: Preserve capital, seek modest growth, and use SGBs’ taxation to your advantage; prefer liquidity via ETFs for any transient needs.
4) Hands-off simplicity: Multi-Asset Funds
Single-fund solutions that typically combine equity + debt + gold under one roof, periodically rebalanced by professionals. Useful for investors who prefer “one and done” simplicity while still having gold exposure. (Category mechanics; taxation depends on underlying composition.)
Deep Dive: Gold Formats in 2025
Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs)
Tenor: 8 years (early exit via redemption windows after year 5; secondary market trading available).
Coupon: 2.5% per annum, paid semi-annually; taxable at slab.
Maturity tax: Capital gains exempt for individuals on redemption by RBI at maturity.
Who should choose: Long-horizon investors comfortable with holding till maturity to unlock the tax benefit.
Gold ETFs / Gold Mutual Funds
Pros: High liquidity, purity assurance, easy execution, ability to pledge.
Cons: Expense ratio and tracking error; LTCG at 12.5% without indexation post-reform.
Who should choose: Investors needing liquidity or systematic accumulation into gold.
Physical Gold
Pros: Tangibility and cultural utility (gifting, jewellery).
Cons: Making charges, purity/assay risks, storage and theft risk; less efficient for investment returns compared to SGB/ETFs.
Deep Dive: Mutual Fund Choices in 2025
Equity Index Funds (Core)
What: Nifty 50/Nifty 100/Nifty Next 50 index funds, or large-cap index ETFs.
Why: Transparent, low cost, captures the market’s long-run growth; historical TR data supports compounding over long windows.
Flexi-cap / Multi-cap Funds (Satellite)
What: Active managers with wider mandates across market caps.
Why: Potential for excess returns vs. index across cycles—but accept tracking error and fund-manager risk.
Mid-/Small-cap Funds (High-beta satellite)
What: Higher growth potential with higher volatility and drawdowns; only for long horizons and disciplined SIPs.
Why: Evidence from 2016–2025 shows mid-caps led performance but at much higher risk—size allocations prudently.
Hybrid / Multi-Asset Funds (All-in-one)
What: Combine equity, debt, and sometimes gold.
Why: Built-in diversification and periodic rebalancing; taxation depends on composition (non-equity components often fall under the 12.5% LTCG without indexation regime post-reform).
Taxation Examples (Illustrative)
Always confirm with a tax professional for your situation; rules can evolve and exemptions can interact with other income.
1. Equity MF sale (on/after July 23, 2024)
Suppose you realise ₹2,15,000 of LTCG in FY 2024–25.
₹1,25,000 exempt; ₹90,000 taxed at 12.5% = ₹11,250 (plus surcharge/cess).
2. SGB held to maturity
You receive 2.5% annual interest (taxable).
At maturity, you pay no capital-gains tax on the redemption amount.
3. Gold ETF held long term
Gains taxed at 12.5% without indexation; if sold within the short-term window, gains are taxed at your slab.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Treating jewellery as an “investment.” Making charges and spreads erode returns; prefer SGBs/ETFs for investing.
Chasing last year’s winners
Mid-/small-caps can reverse sharply; size allocations to your risk capacity.
Ignoring tax thresholds and dates
For equity LTCG, the ₹1.25 lakh exemption and the post-July 23, 2024 regime matter; calculate year-wise.
Skipping rebalancing
Without periodic rebalancing, a rally in one asset (gold or equities) can distort your risk profile.
No emergency fund
Don’t force-sell growth assets to meet emergencies; keep 6–12 months of expenses in liquid debt/cash-equivalents.
Verdicts by Investor Profile (Actionable Guidance)
Young, aggressive investor (long horizon, high risk capacity)
Prioritise equity mutual funds as the main growth engine. Keep 10–15% gold (SGBs if you can hold; ETFs if you want liquidity). Rebalance annually. This maximises compounding while adding a shock absorber.
Mid-career, balanced investor (moderate risk, multiple goals)
Use a core-satellite equity MF approach (50–65% equity), 20–30% debt/hybrid, and 10–15% gold. This mix targets growth and stability, with gold cushioning equity cycles.
Conservative / near-retiree (capital preservation focus)
Keep equity 25–45% (large-cap/index tilt), debt 35–55%, and gold 10–20% via SGBs to leverage tax-free maturity gains. The goal is to protect capital while fighting inflation.
Don’t want to manage multiple funds?
Consider multi-asset funds with built-in gold exposure and periodic rebalancing; check scheme documents and post-reform taxation based on asset mix.
Final Words
In 2025, there isn’t a single winner. Gold excels as a hedge and, via SGBs, offers unique tax efficiency for long-term holders. Equity mutual funds remain the workhorse for wealth creation, supported by decades of return data on Indian equities. Most investors will do best with a thoughtful blend, guided by risk tolerance, time horizon, and the updated capital-gains rules. Stay disciplined with SIPs, rebalance annually, and use your ₹1.25 lakh equity LTCG exemption smartly each year. Each platforms have different kind of terms and conditions. Visit the official website of the platform, which you want to invest. Like SBI Mutual funds: https://www.sbimf.com/
FAQs (2025)
Is gold “safer” than mutual funds?
Gold usually has lower correlation to equities and can cushion drawdowns, but its price still fluctuates. Mutual funds—especially equity funds—are more volatile day-to-day but tend to outperform over long horizons. The “safer” choice depends on timeframe and purpose.
What’s the most tax-efficient way to hold gold?
SGBs—because maturity gains are tax-exempt for individuals, though the 2.5% interest is taxable. ETFs/Gold MFs are liquid but LTCG 12.5% applies without indexation post-reform.
How much gold should be in a portfolio?
Many balanced investors use 5–15% as a range. Back-tests show small gold sleeves can maintain returns while improving the ride; your exact number should reflect your risk and goals.
What equity funds should form the “core”?
Low-cost Nifty 50 / Nifty 100 index funds for core, with optional flexi-cap/mid-cap satellites based on risk. Long-run TR index data supports equity compounding.
Are equity LTCG rules different if I sold units before July 23, 2024?
Yes. The new rates/exemption apply only to sales on/after July 23, 2024; earlier sales follow the prior structure. Track sale dates carefully in FY 2024–25 ITR.
You may also like to read: https://khabarkhabri.com/digital-public-infrastructure-3024/